Tuesday, December 14, 2010

Not So Fast?

Well, I did acknowledge I was no Constitutional scholar; and I pointed out a certain degree to which the judge in question might have a political and personal agenda. So it's not as if I swallowed it whole. Nevertheless, I may have been pessimistic overmuch in my recent post on ruling as unconstitutional the individual mandate part of health care reform:

"I've had a chance to read Judge Hudson's opinion, and it seems to me it has a fairly obvious and quite significant error," writes Orin Kerr, a professor of law at George Washington University, on the generally conservative law blog The Volokh Conspiracy.

Kerr and others note that Hudson's argument against Congress' power to require people to purchase health insurance rests on a tautology.

The key portion of the ruling reads:

If a person's decision not to purchase health insurance at a particular point in time does not constitute the type of economic activity subject to regulation under the Commerce Clause, then logically an attempt to enforce such provision under the Necessary and Proper Clause is equally offensive to the Constitution.

Kerr notes that this is all wrong. The Necessary and Proper Clause allows Congress to take steps beyond those listed in the Constitution to achieve its Constitutional ends, including the regulation of interstate commerce. Hudson's argument wipes a key part of the Constitution out of existence. Kerr says Hudson "rendered [it] a nullity."

So, who knows? I still think my essential prediction is correct: it'll go to the Supreme Court and the hard-core right-wing judicial activists who sit there will hand the loss to Obama the way they handed victory to Bush.

1 comment:

  1. So your against, oh excuse me,
    YOU'RE against our American Constitutional Democracy,(more accurately a Constitutional Republic) founded by Slave Owning Dirty Old White Guys (Would you trust Thomas Jefferson alone with your 15 year old Slave???? I know I wouldn't)Thats the way it works, the Surpreme Court says Abortion's OK and 40 yrs later there's (there are? there would be?) 40 million fewer Black Peoples, Yay Democracy!!
    Or that Mr. Plessy has to pick Mr. Ferguson's Cotton, and you have to wait 90 years till enough Judges die to change it..
    And if you don't wanta wait YOUR state can suceed and start a Civil War, or become a Canadian Province, with that Free Healthcare and Goofy Football Rules (110 yard Field? 12 Players? 3 Downs?????)

    I LIKE the Surpreme Ccurt, they get most things right...



Comments back, moderated. Preference given for those who stay on topic.

Popular posts